December 8, 2020 | Reading Time: 3 minutes

Under Trump, the GOP stopped pretending

For four years, the Republican Party showed its true face.

Share this article

Liberal democracy is not a good thing for political parties of the right. While it can deliver for most people most of the time, liberal democracy can’t for the Republican Party or its counterparts around the globe. Elite members of such political parties have everything they need politically, because they are rich, very rich or very obscenely rich.

They don’t need democratic politics the way you and I need democratic politics, because god-like wealth, status and power have already brought them superlative levels of freedom. What they need, or what they tell themselves they need, is for liberal democracy to get out of the way so they can become even more very obscenely rich.

How far they are willing to go along with Trump depends on how much they see the need to appease liberal democracy.

Democracy won’t get out of the way, so political parties of the right have devised ways of making their goals appear as if they’re everyone’s. They must because their real goals are gothic: minimal if any taxation on their money, especially dynastic money, and minimal if any regulation of the means of adding more to the pile. Most people most of the time don’t care about that, because they have some measure of caring for their fellow human beings. Indeed, they sympathize with the poor and resent the rich. There’s only one thing the conservative rich can possibly do. They lie—and lie and lie.

While the conservative rich really do believe they are better than everyone else—they have “good genes,” after all—they can’t say that. That gets them in trouble. While they really do believe morality is a ploy by the weak (you and me) to defend themselves against the strong (them), they can’t say that. That gets them in trouble. So they spend as much time masking their true intentions as they do gobbling up as much as they can in the barbarous belief that human beings can’t behave better than wild animals.

Here’s the tip jar!

When an anonymous billionaire was asked in July if it’s fair to get richer while the covid pandemic kills Americans and leaves devastation in its wake, he said: “I don’t know. Is war fair? Do people die in a war? Yes. You’ve got a virus that is affecting people. It’s pretty clear who it affects. (He meant people who are old and sick.) So nature is saying, ‘I’m going to pick on you.’ Is it fair? Is it right? No. But that’s life.”

This is social Darwinism, among a repertoire of lies the conservative rich have told us for decades. Their extraordinary wealth, and consequently their extraordinary power, aren’t just natural; they are preferable to the impure hand of government taxing and regulating what they say should not be taxed and regulated, because doing so threatens the economy, a system in which we all have a stake. This lie appeared noble, tied to our collective fate. It was, however, gothic. It was predicated on mass suffering.

It was also very useful during the 40 years that liberal democracy seemed intractable. The conservative rich had to pretend. They had to act as if they cared about equality. They had to make like they loved America. They had to—until Donald Trump came along. Trump told “the truth.” Might equals right, and anyone telling you otherwise is trying to scam you. He was popular with the white working class. The Russians attacked Hillary Clinton but it didn’t cost him. The best part? He could show utter contempt for his own supporters (Mexico’s gonna pay for the wall ha ha!) and they totally fell for it! With his rise came the luxury of not having to fake it anyone.

For the last four years, the Republicans haven’t bothered appeasing liberal democracy with all the many lies they honed to perfection over the years. National character? Didn’t matter. States rights? Didn’t matter. Norms and institutions? Didn’t matter. Civil society? Didn’t matter. “Big government”? Didn’t matter. Budgets and spending? Didn’t matter. Patriotism? Even that didn’t matter. Everything the conservative rich told us they cared about was stripped away. Their true goals—tax cuts, business deregulation, control of judges—were revealed. The GOP showed its true face.

And it continues to. The president isn’t winding down his term. He’s “broadening” a “pressure campaign” to subvert the election and the will of the people. Trump twice called last week the speaker of the Pennsylvania House of Representatives. That’s the third time he has intervened personally in an attempt to stay in office. Federal law requires the US Congress to recognize the election’s outcome, but so far all but 25 Republicans refuse to say Joe Biden won. How far they are willing to go along with Trump depends on how much they see the need to appease liberal democracy.

John Stoehr

John Stoehr is the editor of the Editorial Board. He writes the daily edition. Find him @johnastoehr.


  1. MIGriffin on July 30, 2021 at 11:25 pm

    Republicans show whatever “face” will gets them the most power; there is no “true” version. Starting January 20th, they’ll be screaming again about balancing the budget and reducing the national debt at the expense of social programs, and defending other fake “moral” stances that they haven’t ranted about in 4 years. Their God is selfish greed, not the Christ whose teachings they corrupt for their own purposes. I’m exhausted already.

  2. Luke O'Connor on July 30, 2021 at 11:25 pm

    And Democrats, too, have pretended: that Republicans are a normal political party who disagree in good faith about their vision of government.

    The divide in the Democratic party is between those who would go back to pretending and those who have been fooled enough.

    • Jonathan Epps on July 30, 2021 at 11:25 pm

      That’s the part hardest for me to understand. Like the current talk about pursuing Trump for crimes or even talking too harshly about his horrible administration will divide the country. We’re divided. To NOT pursue him and hold him and more importantly his enablers accountable, will be condoning their actions and inviting more of worse.

    • John Stoehr on July 30, 2021 at 11:25 pm

      Dems are pretending less than they used to. That’s the only positive.

  3. Daniel Pepper on July 30, 2021 at 11:25 pm

    Excellent observations. How do we respond over the next 4 years as the GOP hypocrites rediscover their ‘values?’

  4. Wendy Rawady on July 30, 2021 at 11:25 pm

    What is the ‘forty years’ referring to? I am a bit confused. Good article otherwise, and Social Darwinism is a great label. As noted below by Luke O’Connor, all sides ‘pretend’ for instance, Hillary pretended that her husband was a moral man when in fact, he played out immorality in plain sight. As did JFK. The GOP have just taken greed, entitlement, bad taste, lies and ignorance to new levels.

  5. Jim Prevatt on July 30, 2021 at 11:25 pm

    Fine article, John. I always try to remember, especially at this time of year, words from Mary’s song:
    “He has filled the hungry with good things, *
    and the rich he has sent away empty.”
    Guess we’ll just have to wait and see; and when will that be? Someday or century. Meanwhile, we Democrats can try to do what needs doing and always speaking truth to power.

Leave a Comment

Want to comment on this post?
Click here to upgrade to a premium membership.