February 26, 2020 | Reading Time: 4 minutes

My Politics Is Black. Yours Should Be, Too

Why I'm Bernie-skeptical, not anti-Bernie.


Share this article

Yesterday, someone alleged that I was “vehemently anti-Bernie.” The context was a comment I made about youth voting. I said no one ever won the presidency counting on young voters turning out. My critic demurred, but he went farther. “Why should anyone take your pessimistic (anti-Bernie bias) rewrite (opinion) of history seriously? The youth vote for [Barack] Obama was unprecedented and he (checks notes) won.”

Don’t get me wrong. My critic is entitled to his opinion. If he thinks I’m “vehemently anti-Bernie,” more power to him. I bring this up because I think it’s a convenient illustration of something I want to talk about today, which is that my politics is black.

Black politics is pragmatic. It isn’t pie in the sky. It isn’t Pollyanna. It isn’t the bright side. It sees clearly.

The history of African-American politics is the history of republican liberalism in this country. What black people have achieved is what the founders wanted Americans to achieve, and, yes, that’s in spite of their owning black people. Small-r republican liberalism demands representative government, individual liberty, equal protection under the law, and the cultivation of the common good. It honors freedom but demands responsibility. Citizens are not taxpayers. They are not consumers. They are citizens—the greatest gift of self-empowerment God ever bestowed on humanity.

Black history, in my view, is a history of making good on the Constitution’s preamble. “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.” It’s all right here. Democracy and brotherhood, equal justice and equal peace, security and prosperity—all the ideological hallmarks of black political thought and republican liberalism.

Black politics is hopeful because it must be in order to survive being cheated, robbed, humiliated or murdered in America. There is no sane person who ever gave up on hope. There is no moral conviction that is hopeless. You must believe tomorrow can be better even though you have every reason to believe it won’t be. You must believe this not for yourself, but for your children (your “Posterity”). Nihilism is a white luxury. (Black conservatism comes close, though; it believes white people are immutably racist.)

Because black politics must be hopeful in order to survive—as well as thrive—hope is therefore pragmatic. It isn’t pie in the sky. It isn’t Pollyanna. It isn’t the bright side. It sees clearly. It must, because America is no place for false hope. While white people entertained themselves after 2008 with the idea of a “post-racial” America, no black person did. Yet Obama’s victory was indisputable evidence of its future possibility.

Black history, moreover, is a history of (often violent) white forces trying to stop the preamble, as well as the Declaration of Independence and the 14 Amendment, from becoming a permanent reality. To put this another way, black history is a history of white supremacy and white violence. Yet another way: black politics is anti-fascism.

Too few white Americans, in my estimation, understand that white supremacy, white nationalism, ethnonationalism, or whatever you want to call it is just another name for fascism. Too few white people understand that the “white” in white supremacy changes according to the contingencies of history. In this country, Italians weren’t white a century ago. Neither were the Irish. In Germany, Slavs weren’t white during the Nazi era. Neither were the Jews. Neither were homosexuals nor the mentally ill.

Too few white Americans understand many conservative policies are fascist. For instance, policies forcing citizens to work in order to demonstrate that they are deserving of public assistance. The Nazis practiced an extreme version of the same belief. Arbeit macht frei (“Labor makes you free”) was displayed prominently over the gates of some of their prison camps. But free from what? From being who you are. You get public assistance after you stop being yourself. Impossible, of course, and that’s the point of such policies—to make the outcomes of sadist policies seem like a moral failing.

Most of Bernie Sanders’ most vocal supporters are white, and it puzzles them why black Americans are not backing the Vermont senator. From their perspective, black Americans would benefit the most from universal health care, greater job security, and higher taxation on the economic elites cheating black Americans out of their wealth.

They are right, of course, but that’s beside the point. The question isn’t whether black Americans want these things. (Black Americans have fought, bled and died for these and similar things.) The question is whether they can trust Sanders. More importantly, the question is whether they can trust white Americans to underwrite black American investment in Sanders. They say he will win by bringing out the youth vote. Will he?

My critic thinks so. Obama did it. Sanders can, too.

Obama didn’t. He supplemented his win with young voters. But his win didn’t depend on them. Things are different for Sanders. According to a new study, he’s probably going to push a lot of voters away. To win, he must get new voters, young ones, and to do that, he must drive out a percentage of young voters no one has ever driven out.

I’m not vehemently anti-Bernie. I’m not anti-Bernie. I’m Bernie-skeptical, though.

My politics is black. Yours* should be, too.

—John Stoehr

(*Apologies to my readers whose politics is already black!)

John Stoehr is the editor of the Editorial Board. He writes the daily edition. Find him @johnastoehr.


  1. Hal on Wheels on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

    Thanks for the concise read. You put words “Bernie-skeptical” to my thoughts.
    Hall on Wheels

  2. Leslie M., Eastern KS on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

    Sheesh, John! ‘Likes’ three days in a row! 😉

  3. danamo on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am


  4. Fred Pollack on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

    From an evolution perspective, “We are all Africans”. I use to have this T-shirt (https://centerforinquiry.org/store/product/we-are-all-africans-short-sleeved-t-shirt/). And, on the back, it had this: “The Bible says modern people are the result of incestuous relations Cain and his brothers had with their sisters. Science says we are all descendants of Africans. I believe science.”

  5. Lib on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am


  6. realsaramerica on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

    I’m also Bernie-skeptical, especially after asking my class yesterday if anyone was paying attention to the election. Not a single one… And after Bernie tried to pivot without answering a question last night, even my less Bernie skeptical son groaned and said, “Oh COME ON.”

    • John Stoehr on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

      Which class and where?

      • realsaramerica on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

        Intro to the Creative Process at WCSU. I’m teaching full-time in the Writing dept this semester. The one where I asked the question was an intro level writing class with students mostly studying other subjects: nursing, biology, social work etc. Just out of curiosity, I’ll ask in my other classes this week.

        • John Stoehr on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

          Yes, please do report to the rest of us what you find. Thanks!

  7. Thornton Prayer on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

    This analysis is dead on. I of course can’t speak for other African-Americans, but I am confident that many black people are leery of gambling this election on a fantasy turnout of young voters and non-voters which never materializes. If young people couldn’t turn out in 1972 in the face of being drafted for an unpopular war AND having recently won the right to vote, then almost nothing is likely to change that pattern.

    Primaries attract partisans and the politically aware which is not the majority of the electorate. I believe that those us who constantly monitor what is happening politically forget this essential fact. For a variety of reasons, large percentages of younger people require even more political maturation before voting in greater numbers….at which point they are no longer young voters.

    My biggest frustration is that the social and political capital that many white liberals and progressives can squander on fantasy campaigns would leave them relatively unscathed if Sanders were to lose the general election. Meanwhile, people like me without that type of capital will confront an entrenched white nationalist regime if the oval office occupier is re-elected. My parents instilled in me the necessary of not just voting but voting smart aka pragmatically. I just hope more people would do the same.

  8. Burgs on July 30, 2021 at 8:06 am

    Nominating Bernie will result in an utter disaster. I really hope we don’t do it.

    I’ll be voting for Biden Tuesday.

Leave a Comment

Want to comment on this post?
Click here to upgrade to a premium membership.