Are cops being sincere?

In the Monday edition of the Editorial Board, I noted the different ways police departments are handling public outrage, some of it violent, over the murder of George Floyd by a white cop in Minneapolis.

Some are flying the Thin Blue Line flag, a symbol of American fascism, while others, including here in New Haven, are taking the time to “renew their vows” to the cities they serve by reciting their oaths.

Pointing this out, I argued, is important, because the president wants to be seen as being on the side of law enforcement so that whatever future action he authorizes will be seen as legit and right. But law enforcement is itself divided, or appears to be. And that’s where today’s question comes from.

Some police officers may be paying lip service to democratic values when they take a knee. If so, does that mean their gestures are meaningless or does that mean citizens can hold them to a standard? Given the reaction to my piece, some are suggesting it’s all public relations and a moot point.

But I’m skeptical and want to know what you think. Thoughts? —John Stoehr

PS: my students will be participating in this thread. Be nice, please!